Classic New York Pies
Our Famous Cheese Pie
Shredded mozzarella, Italian herbs, spices, homemade tomato sauce. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$11.00
Margherita Pie
The original pizza. Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil, garlic, olive oil.
$13.00
Bayside Bianca Pie
White pizza. Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic & Italian spices.
$13.00
The Sicilian
A thick seasoned crust, topped with sauce, mozzarella, Italian herbs & spices.
$26.00
Specialty Pizza
Manhattan Meat Lover's Pie
Pepperoni, meatballs, smoked bacon, mozzarella.
$14.00
Queen's Deluxe Pie
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, mozzarella.
$14.00
Rosale's Vegetarian Pie
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, mozzarella.
$14.00
The "Killer Bee" Pie
Our "famous" cheese pie topped with Char & Cup Pepperoni and drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey.
$15.00
Hawaiian Pie
Ham & pineapple on our traditional pizza pie.
$13.00
APB Alfredo Pizza
Creamy Alfredo sauce, Italian herbs, garlic, mozzarella.
$13.00
Mariano Pie
Olive oil, diced tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella.
$13.00
Rustic Salsiccia Pie
Fresh mozzarella, Italian fennel sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic cloves, grated parmesan, accented with crushed red peppers.
$11.00
Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken Pie
Grilled chicken with a layer of wing sauce, mozzarella, with a swirl of bleu cheese dressing.
$14.00
DA, Bronx BBQ Chicken Pie
BBQ & pizza sauce topped with chicken, red onions, mozzarella.
$11.00
Carnegie Hall Chicken Club Pie
Smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, mozzarella, grilled chicken, topped with ranch dressing.
$15.00
Staten Island Stuffed Pie
A double layer of dough stuffed with any two toppings, mozzarella & a side of sauce.
$26.00
The Witness Protection Program
Pop's Pesto Pie
Pop's own pesto sauce, tomato slices, mozzarella. Contains Pignoli nuts.
$16.00
Wickle Pickle Pie
Sweet & Spicy Wickles Pickles, bacon, mozzarella, alfredo sauce with a ranch drizzle after cook.
$17.00
Bocce Bolognese Pie
Homemade Bolognese, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil.
$16.00
Chelsea Market Sweet Heat Pie
Our Classic Bianca Pie, sausage, caramelized onion drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey after cook.
$16.00
Appetizers
Garlic Knots
Freshly baked knots with garlic, butter & herbs.
$5.00
Housemade Fried Pickles
$8.00
Chicken Wings
Choice of mild, medium, hot, garlic butter, teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or BBQ sauce.
$10.00
Chicken Tenders
Battered tenders served with a side of honey mustard, BBQ sauce, or buffalo style.
$12.00
Boneless Chicken Wings
$16.00
Mom's Meatballs
Made with Mom's special ingredients.
$6.00
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with a side of our homemade marinara sauce.
$10.00
Fried Raviolis
Ravioli lightly fried & served with our homemade marinara sauce.
$11.00
Jones Beach Fries
A basket of fries without the beach, just the salt!
$6.00
House Soup
$5.00
Fresh Salads
House Salad
$6.00
Caesar Salad
$4.00
Chicken Caesar Salad
$9.00
Little Italy Antipasta Salad
Salami, ham, pepperoni & provolone cheese, pinwheels, on Iceberg lettuce, with tomatoes, black & green olives, red onions, pepperoncinis.
$19.00
Broadway Bleu Cheese Salad
Romaine, bleu cheese crumbles, red onions, diced tomatoes, cinnamon roasted nuts.
$8.00
Astoria Greek Salad
Traditional Kalamata olives, pepperoncini, onions, tomatoes, roasted red peppers & feta cheese.
$5.00
Soho Cobb Salad
Iceberg, chicken, smoked bacon, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, red onions, crumbled bleu cheese.
$19.00
Columbus Circle Caprese Salad
Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Tomato, Fresh Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oli and a Drizzle of Balsamic Vinaigrette Glaze.
$15.00
Calzones & Specialty Rolls
Swat Team Stromboli
Ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella.
$16.00
Patrolman's Pepperoni Roll
Triple pepperoni with double mozzarella.
$14.00
Sergant's Sausage Roll
Italian sausage, onions, green peppers, mozzarella.
$14.00
Jail Bird Chicken Roll
Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Mozzarella Cheese served with a side of ranch dressing.
$17.00
Convict Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella & herb ricotta cheese mix.
$17.00
Gourmet Heroes
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
$13.00
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$14.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
$13.00
Penn Station Cheesesteak Hero
$15.00
Italian Combo Hero
$13.00
Pasta & Specialty Dishes
Pasta Marinara
Homemade marinara sauce, with choice of pasta.
$14.00
Pasta Marinara with Meatballs
Homemade Marinara Sauce, with your choice of pasta, topped with two of our Mom's Meatballs.
$18.00
Pasta Bolognese
Our homemade meat sauce with choice of pasta.
$19.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
Made with heavy cream & a blend of Italian cheese.
$18.00
Baked Ziti
Ricotta & mozzarella, baked "well done".
$18.00
Homemade Lasagna
Layers of pasta, sausage, meatballs, marinara, ricotta & mozzarella.
$23.00
Chicken Parmigiana
Imported Romano cheese, mozzarella, marinara, served with choice of pasta.
$23.00
Eggplant Parmigiana
Imported Romano cheese, mozzarella, marinara, served with choice of pasta.
$18.00
Desserts
Zeppoles
Our special dough fried, covered in powdered or cinnamon sugar.
$6.00
Mini New York Cannolis
A mini pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream dusted with powdered sugar.
$5.00
New York Cannoli
A crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream dusted with powdered sugar.
$9.00
Junior's Famous New York Cheesecake
Award-winning celebrated. Infamous, hand-made with premium ingredients.
$10.00
Chocolate Triple Layer Cake
A dark chocolate cake layered high filled with a rich chocolate cream filling.
$7.00
Beverages
Fountain Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza
$4.00
Fresh Brewed Tea
$4.00
2 Liter Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza
$6.00
20 Ounce Soda Bottle
$4.00
Water
$3.00
Coffee
$3.00
Hot Tea
$3.00
NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay
Enjoy the best pizza in Orlando like the locals do. Local residents have made NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay one of the most popular in the area. Sample what they have to offer and see if you agree. Immerse yourself in the culinary scene of Orlando with some of the area's top dishes. These classics are popular for a reason, so go ahead and see what all the fuss is about. See why the locals rave about Our Famous Cheese Pie at NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay. This local favorite is popular for a reason. Complete your meal with 2 liter soda, it's a great way to make dinner into a feast. NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay has been a Slice partner for 4 years. This local business is a feature of the community it serves. You can get your pizza to go with curbside pickup from NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay. Grab something tasty on your way home. Check out NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay's other locations for some of the best pizza in the area. Try everything they offer at a location that's convenient for you. Pay by credit card to make the checkout process easier. Follow NYPD Pizza of Lake Cay on social media to keep up with the latest news.
Full Hours